Sunday, January 25, 2009

Revival of Confucianism Threatening Christianity?

Purdue University professor Yang Fenggang spoke about the revival of Confucianism in China in an article titled Cultural Dynamics in China: Today and in 2020 (2007).

Even though he claimed that "Confucian fundamentalists proclaim the superiority and uniqueness of Chinese culture centered around Confucianism, emphasize the uniqueness of the Chinese social situation, and reject liberty, equality and democracy as notions of western culture," little evidence was provided to back his assertion.

The sociology professor added: "These fundamentalists are unapologetically elitist and have offered cultural and nationalistic justifications for political authoritarianism. They have also generated some popular sentiments against Western cultural influences in China, including western socio-political philosophies, including liberalism."

The only piece of evidence Yang had thrown up was the signing of an open letter by ten Chinese PhD students arguing against Christmas celebrations.

Even so, Yang concluded that "if this trend continues without restraint, the Confucianists revival movement will likely make Christianity the direct target of attacks, as occurred in the Boxer Rebellion around 1900 and the anti-Christian movement in the 1920s. History is likely to repeat itself."

More evidence is needed to support your conclusion, Prof Yang. And besides, what is the linkage between the revival of Confucianism and the attack on Christianity? Why should one necessarily lead to the other?

2 Comments:

At 5:58 AM, Blogger 葉鵬飛 said...

推荐杨教授去读蒋庆的《政治儒学》(我手上是台北养正堂文化。民国92年版),他批评西方民主缺乏王道的政治理想,容易流于平庸;也分析中国文化与基督教的“永恒冲突”但提出解决之道。但我同意中国的儒学复兴并不必然导致义和团似的排斥基督教的结果。这个判断太简单。

 
At 1:28 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Keep posting stuff like this i really like it

 

Post a Comment

<< Home